Table of contents

1. Platform architecture and flexibility2. Features and out-of-the-box capabilities3. Performance and scalability4. Developer experience and tech stack5. Total cost of ownership (TCO)6. Time to market and ease of launch7. Security and compliance8. Ecosystem and support9. Migration complexity and costWho should choose which platform?How to get started

Get the industry’s most secure Magento hosting◦ 99.99% uptime
◦ Comprehensive security
◦ 24/7 support

Magento Guide → Vs Commercetools

Commercetools vs Magento [2025]

Choosing the right ecommerce platform can shape the future of your business. Whether you’re launching a new storefront or scaling enterprise operations, Commercetools and Magento (Adobe Commerce) offer two very different approaches to modern commerce.

Host Magento at full throttle.

Get secure, reliable Magento hosting so you can scale faster.

Magento hosting

Commercetools vs Magento: key differences at a glance

Feature	Commercetools	Magento / Adobe Commerce
Architecture	Headless, API-first, microservices-based	Monolith (with optional headless support)
Hosting Model	SaaS, cloud-native	Self-hosted (Open Source) or PaaS (Adobe Commerce Cloud)
Built-in Features	Minimal core, composable via APIs	Full-featured admin, checkout, promotions
Customization	Highly flexible with custom frontend	Extensive via PHP modules or APIs
Pricing Model	Usage-based (GMV, API calls)	License + infrastructure or free (OSS)
Developer Stack	Language-agnostic backend, JS frontend	PHP backend, GraphQL/React frontend
Ecosystem	Emerging, enterprise-focused	Mature, broad community and marketplace
Time to Market	Fast for MVPs, longer for full builds	Medium to slow depending on project size
Ideal Use Case	Enterprises with composable commerce needs	SMBs to large businesses with flexible needs

Key differences between Commercetools and Magento

Commercetools and Magento represent two different philosophies in ecommerce platform design. Commercetools is built on the MACH (Microservices, API-first, Cloud-native, Headless) approach, while Magento is a powerful open-source monolith that can function in both traditional and headless environments.

Magento Open Source offers robust features out of the box, with Adobe Commerce layering in more advanced tools. Commercetools, on the other hand, gives you a minimal backend and expects you to build or connect your own frontend, CMS, search, and checkout systems.

1. Platform architecture and flexibility

Commercetools is natively headless and fully modular. Every component—from cart logic to catalog management—is API-driven. This flexibility lets you build exactly what you need, but also demands a team capable of orchestrating multiple services.

Magento’s architecture is monolithic at its core but has grown increasingly API-friendly. You can go headless using Magento PWA Studio or integrate with Vue, React, or even native mobile apps. Magento’s modular PHP backend allows deep customization with thousands of community or enterprise extensions.

2. Features and out-of-the-box capabilities

Magento shines with its built-in admin interface, promotion engine, catalog management, advanced checkout, and support for complex product types and multi-store setups. It also has robust B2B functionality through Adobe Commerce.

Commercetools intentionally limits built-in features to provide a lean, flexible core. You’ll need to bring your own CMS, payment gateway, and frontend—but that’s a strength for businesses building highly customized ecommerce experiences.

3. Performance and scalability

Commercetools leverages cloud-native architecture for excellent horizontal scalability. It scales automatically based on traffic and handles microservice orchestration in the background.

Magento can scale effectively, but only with the right infrastructure. Adobe Commerce Cloud includes autoscaling and cloud management, but Open Source users must handle performance tuning themselves. Caching, CDN, and hosting setup are critical to delivering fast load times on Magento.

4. Developer experience and tech stack

Commercetools appeals to modern dev teams that prefer freedom over convention. You can build your frontend in any language or framework, and its backend is language-agnostic via APIs.

Magento is PHP-based and requires knowledge of its specific architecture and conventions. Frontend development can be modernized with PWA Studio or decoupled entirely, but it still benefits from Magento-specific expertise.

Both platforms offer GraphQL support and well-documented APIs, but Commercetools is closer to a “blank slate,” whereas Magento provides more out-of-the-box structure.

5. Total cost of ownership (TCO)

Commercetools uses a usage-based pricing model, typically based on gross merchandise volume (GMV), number of API calls, and services consumed. While you’ll save on hosting and infrastructure, development costs can be high since so much has to be built.

Magento Open Source has no license cost but does require hosting and skilled developers. Adobe Commerce has a significant license fee but includes managed hosting and a more complete feature set.

TCO for both platforms depends on your scale and internal capabilities. Magento may be more affordable for mid-sized businesses; Commercetools is often more predictable for high-GMV enterprises.

6. Time to market and ease of launch

Magento’s monolithic design and rich ecosystem of templates and extensions mean you can often get a store up and running faster, especially if you’re using Magento Open Source and not customizing heavily.

Commercetools can launch MVPs quickly with prebuilt integrations, but full production builds usually take longer due to the need to compose your stack (CMS, search, checkout, etc.).

7. Security and compliance

Commercetools handles hosting and platform security, making it easier to maintain compliance with SOC 2, ISO 27001, and GDPR. Its cloud-native setup also means no server maintenance or patching for your team.

Magento Open Source relies on your hosting and update practices. Adobe Commerce adds automated patches and compliance support. Either way, security is more hands-on for Magento users unless you use managed Magento hosting.

8. Ecosystem and support

Magento’s ecosystem is massive. Thousands of extensions, themes, and certified developers make it easier to find help or plug in features.

Commercetools has a smaller but growing ecosystem focused on enterprise tools and composable integrations. It’s backed by strong partner agencies and has gained traction in headless-first use cases.

9. Migration complexity and cost

Magento has a mature migration ecosystem, especially for moving from Magento 1 or WooCommerce. Extensions, data migration tools, and hosting partners streamline the process.

Commercetools typically requires a full replatforming effort. Since it’s API-first, everything—from frontend to integrations—needs to be re-architected. While this creates long-term flexibility, the short-term investment is substantial.

Expect migration to Commercetools to take longer and cost more, especially if you’re leaving a monolithic system. The trade-off is a future-ready stack built for growth.

Who should choose which platform?

Commercetools is a great fit for:

Large enterprises with global operations
Businesses moving toward composable commerce
Teams with strong frontend and API integration capabilities

Magento is ideal for:

Mid-market businesses seeking rich features out of the box
Companies that want the flexibility to go headless later
Teams with PHP developers or Magento experience

Next steps for choosing between Commercetools and Magento

Both Commercetools and Magento are powerful platforms—but they solve different problems for different teams. Commercetools offers unmatched flexibility and scalability for businesses ready to invest in custom builds. Magento delivers rich features and proven ecommerce capabilities for businesses that want flexibility and structure.

If you’re weighing the switch or planning a new ecommerce initiative, start by mapping your team’s capabilities, your budget, and how fast you need to launch.

Ready to upgrade your Magento experience? Professional hosting improves speeds, security, and reliability for a website and a brand that people find engaging and trustworthy.

Liquid Web offers the raw infrastructure power you need with mission-critical features that keep your store running smoothly. Most importantly, our in-house Magento experts are standing by to help with both hosting and Magento application roadblocks.

Click through below to explore all of our Magento hosting options, or chat with an expert right now to get answers and advice.